Dr. Amy Colwell, MD

Results disappointing for skin sparing double mastectomy. Amy Colwell did the reconstruction part of my skin sparing double mastectomy. First off, tear shaped implants were not used. Second, the donor skin that was used on top of my implants was not wrapped properly, and are lumpy under my skin. Finally, the stitches that were done are absolutely horrific and Frankenstein in appearance. With another derm doc recently, I had to have a large skin surgery , and the stitches were not even visible after healing. How could Dr. Caldwel not do a similar type of stitch? I have horrible scarring along the stitches that she did under my implants. Additionally, after this incredibly emotional surgery, I never heard from the staff. No one followed up to see how I was doing. Also, prior to the surgery, it was incredibly hard to find images of what to expect. All very disappointing. Ask many questions before this necessary surgery.

After six months, I got in to see Dr. Colwell. I was there for a breast reduction and lift consult as I had lost 75 pounds and my breasts were hanging at my waist. She didn’t have much to say. I told her that I had osteoarthritis in my spine due to the weight of my breasts. She said that I would be a good candidate for the procedure. I was ready to make my next appointment to move forward and she seems surprised. I had to ask her to take the pictures so that we could show the insurance company how much weight I had lost, and that the reduction was necessary. A few weeks later her assistant called and told me that insurance did not approve surgery because they didn’t think it was warranted. I asked her to advocate for me as my weight loss doctor had and said she just needed to have the doctor call the insurance company and explain. The assistant refused. Terrible service. If this is the service before, I’d hate to see the after care. Looking elsewhere.

I am forever grateful to Dr. Colwell and her team. They made this process seamless, and my results are amazing!

I decided on a double mastectomy with nipple sparing surgery after chemotherapy. While I agree with some commenters that Dr. Colwell doesn't say much, I wasn't mentally able to do a lot of research or retain information for my consult anyways. If you are in a position to be ready for your consult, do your research and make a list of questions. She will explain everything in layman's terms. I almost didn't elect to have any reconstruction because I was so done with breast cancer. Personally, I decided to trust in a doctor that didn't need to sell herself or the results I would have. I found that reassuring. I had two surgeries. The first required tissue expanders, and the second surgery replaced them with implants. The initial surgery is a major surgery. My final "scarring" after both surgeries is almost exactly on the same line as the original surgery incision. I love the results. I look amazing. Dr. Colwell is a blessing.

I have been working with Dr. Colwell for two years during a breast reconstruction. From the beginning she has been dismissive, her office is unresponsive, they gave me advice which was a misrepresentation of my options, and the results are not satisfactory. I wish I'd chosen a different doctor and am now having complications. I will be switching providers but please, look for another provider and save yourself the emotional and physical pain and discomfort I've experienced!

Same experience almost exactly. Scheduled for revision and am hoping for things to be corrected fully. Staff was nice though

I would not recommend Dr. Colwell to anyone. I went to her for reconstructive surgery. She completely botched it. I have contacted another reconstructive surgeon to see if he can fix her mess. I wish I could give her a zero. Her nurse practitioner is training herself on the job and caused me significant pain. Patient calls are not returned for days. If they need medical attention, they cannot get it. I now have a horizontal line across my chest caused by Dr. Colwell.

I had a Breast reduction with Dr Colwell, I was very disappointed with the outcome. The nipples are different in appearance and asymmetric. I went back to see her to voice my concerns, she was dismissive and rude. I wish I could give her 0 stars! Do your research to avoid a similar experience.

I've been a patient of Dr. Colwell's for the past year, as I have been going through breast cancer treatment. Dr. Colwell performed my breast reconstruction, along with added procedures including a neck lift, labioplasty and fat grafting to the face. She is a true artist! Going through breast cancer has been challenging, however, glimmers of doing a few extras for myself, have given me additional confidence to face the world as a middle age woman - feeling a whole lot younger, thanks to Amy!!

She did my reconstruction after double mastectomy. Great doctor, amazing results.

Dr Amy Colwell was the plastic surgeon after my double mastectomy. Before surgery Dr. Colwell told me that there was an 80percent chance that she could install the implants at the same time. That did not happen and she installed the space keepers. In a second surgery later on she installed the permanent implants. Despite the two steps the final result is less that pleasing and my nipples are low and not parallel. Had bad experience with the impersonal care the day of 2nd surgery.

I was referred to Doctor Colwell, and I couldn't have asked for a better surgeon. She is outstanding, she listened and understood how i wanted to keep a very natural and conservative result from my breast lift with augmentation. She took the time to explain the procedure and answer all my questions, always made me feel at ease. The final result was amazing, could not imagine better. Her staff was great! I would definitely recommend Doctor Colwell for anyone seeking plastic surgery.

I am one week post op and can't describe how great I feel and how happy I am with my breast reduction. Dr. Colwell is an artist who took my discomfort and replaced it with joy! The entire ensemble - the anaestheiologists, the nurses, the hospital (MGH), was flawless in their care of me. So happy with my decision and the end result. Thank you Dr. Colwell and staff!!

Dr. Colwell exceeded my expectations. Professional and friendly - her staff are as delightful as they are competent!!!

I had an excellent experience with Dr. Colwell. She truly cares about her patients. My consult with her was very thorough and she answered all of my questions. I had a tummy tuck and breast augmentation and my results were extraordinary! I feel better than I have ever felt about my body image. I love the way I look and I would definitely recommend Dr. Amy Colwell to a friend or family member.

I have had nothing but professional, caring, considerate and thorough visits with Dr. Colwell. Prophylactic double mastectomy with nipple sparing went great. I can't believe how the scars are disappearing! I have had a few other surgeries and wish the scars were as small as these. Great team with Dr. Specht.

She is really good at what she does. She did my breast reconstruction after a double mastectomy and did a great job. Very happy. Not very talkative or personable. Her receptionist could be nicer.

Terrible bedside manner Terrible care Would not recommend

Dr Colwell is an incredibly talented surgeon. She did both a tummy tuck and, few years later, a butt lift for me and I could not be happier. The scars were minimal right after surgery and basically are none existent now. (this is why I chose her...she invented a minimally scarring incision technique). My husband loves the result so much he frequently jokes that we should leave money to Dr Colwell in our Will :) She also has a sweet, kind bedside manner. I highly recommend her

Dr. Colwell does more nipple-sparing mastectomies than anyone else in the Boston area and knows how to make them work for patients who have been turned away by other plastic surgeons who haven't yet mastered her techniques. Inferolateral incision leaves minimal scarring too. She is hard to teach outside of appointments so come prepared with all your questions.