Dr. Anthony Scillia, MD

My son suffered a sports injury to his knee. Dr. Scillia was recommended by our pediatric orthopedic physician to perform the surgery. His diagnosis and surgery recommendation were absolutely spot-on. His staff at his office AND the surgery center were extremely kind, efficient, and helpful. Dr. Scillia is current on cutting edge research and procedures. And, to top it off, he helped me help my son manage his pain through OTC ibuprofen and acetaminophen and ice packs as I did not want my son taking opioids. My son is recovering very quickly and with very little pain and discomfort.

Dr. Scillia is the kindest, greatest doctor around! After years of suffering hamstring pain, he was the ONLY doctor who properly diagnosed it, and then did surgery to re-attach the hamstring to the hip. 10 months AFTER the surgery, I wrote to him that the pain returned, and he scheduled me for a consultation with him. When he realized that my insurance had changed and was not under his office plan, he insisted that I still come for a free appointment. He is a genuine doctor, who really cares about his patients.

Dr Scilia performed a right shoulder replacement on me 2 years ago. To this day my shoulder is like new. No more constant pain or discomfort. No more sleepless nights. Dr. Scilia is one of the most informative and nicest people you will ever meet Dr.Scilia and his team are organized and very professional. He will never rush his patients and will address any and all concerns. Most importantly he is one hell of a surgeon!

Dr. Scillia performed rotator cuff and bicep tenodesis surgery on each of my shoulders five years apart (right shoulder in 2015 and left shoulder in February 2020). In both cases I could not have been more satisfied with Dr. Scillia, his staff (Alex, Erica etc...), and my results. Before discussing surgery, non-surgical options were considered. But being I had extensive damage (which was the case in each shoulder) these options did not provide relief from my pain, weakness, etc, which was not only getting in the way of my training, but even just everyday life. But after each surgery, the repaired shoulder felt stronger and more pain free than they have ever been. I am very excited because I train hard, and now I can do it pain free! Also, the time he takes to explain everything both before and after the surgery makes it seem like you are the most important patient he has. I HIGHLY recommend him!

Dr. Scillia no word will be enough to descript him clearly , he is the top of all surgeon on his field , I had both knees reconstruction surgeries due to ACL tears and injury , he was able to do all repair required and replace the both ACL . I have no pain and both knees functions normally . I have to say that this great man also behind his business great team such Alex and Erica who follow patients everywhere from hospital to final recovery to prior authorizations to paper work and many . Thanks to all . Dr . Anthony does need recommendation or review because his work light speaks about him .

Dr. Scillia, Erica and Alex are an amazing team! Every encounter with this office has been met with a professional yet warm and caring attitude. When no other doctor I consulted for my pain was willing to help me, Dr. Scillia was. He is an amazing surgeon, has a wonderful bedside manner and takes the time to listen carefully to his patients. He is truly concerned and it is evident in the care he provides. I am a health care professional as well and recommend him without hesistation.

usually don't give reviews but i think Dr Scillia and his staff certainly deserve one. I had my ACL and Meniscus fixed by Dr Scillia on Nov 6th 2016. Its now June and i have been back to running for the past 2 months and have been averaging 20 to 25 miles a week with minimal soreness. I think Dr Scillia did an excellent job on my knee. He has great bedside manners and i would highly recommend him. His staff is friendly, courteous and easily reachable.

Dr. Anthony Scillia is the most amazing Ortho Surgeon that I have ever met and/or researched. Other Ortho Surgeons told me I would never be at 100% with the type of knee reconstruction I would have to have but I decided to go with Dr. Scillia and I have 100% of my knee function with no pain. He's a great person and explains everything in detail so that I understand and is also more than willing to take his time answering my questions. He's half man, half amazing! The best!

Dr Scilia operated on both my shoulders for rotator cuff and torn biceps. My shoulders are much better than before. Within 3 weeks I regained full range of motion and my post surgery experience was virtually pain free. I am 64, and recently decline bench pressed 225 lbs. (not the doctors instructions). Dr Scilia did a GREAT JOB!!!!!!!!

Dr. Scillia did a great job repairing my hip. I need a left hip labrum repair and the entire experience was just fantastic. My recovery has moved along better than I could have expected. If any one needs any kind of hip surgery I highly recommend you go see Dr. Scillia! It will be the best decision you ever made!

Dr Scillia was extremely helpful in diagnosing my rare injury (lisfranc displacement) after other doctors misread my x-rays. He has remained a helpful point of contact as I have progressed in my recovery, and I am happily back to 100%. He's the best!

I have played football most of my life and naturally my body has endured a number of injuries, some of which became rather debilitating. Dr. Scillia at NJOI was central to my rehabilitation and put me on the right path to recovery. He successfully repaired my lateral meniscus, my thumb and third metacarpal, and both shoulders. Dr. Scillia and his team provided excellent care while maintaining high standards of service. Thanks to them, I am able to lead an active and healthy life!

I went to see him for my knee and he only recommended treatment when it was absolutely necessary . He is truly an honest doctor

Dr. Scillia has treated several family members. He is wonderful. He takes as much time with his patients as they need. His surgical skills are unsurpassed.

Dr Scillia diagnosed my back problem in one visit and set up physical therapy. Within one month I was off pain Meds and back to work. John

I went to two physicians prior to seeing Dr Scillia Dr Scillia took great care of me and now I am back playing tennis I highly recommend him

I went to Dr Scillia when I blew out my knee a couple of years ago. I still follow up with him and my knee is doing great. I’m able to play sports and I have no pain. He is an excellent sports doctor.

Dr. Scillia has treated me for back pain. He has been able to help me avoid surgery and remain pain free. I feel much better and would highly recommend him. He addressed all my questions, and he is very knowledgeable about current treatments.

I have been treated by Dr Scillia on several occasions. He has been skilled and professional and I feel I have received the finest treatment available.

Dr. Scillia is an excellent doctor who treated my injury after several other doctors could not come up with the righ treatment. He is extremely knowledgeable and listened to everything I had to say. I have finally recovered thanks to Dr. Scillia and highly recommend him.