Dr. Robert Fenstermaker, MD

Dr. Fenstermaker removed a meningioma tumor the size of a golf ball from my brain 9 years ago and was able to remove the whole tumor. He was thorough in explaining the surgical procedure and reassured me of his knowledge and expertise. Regular follow-up visits were scheduled over the past 9 years to be sure of no new growth of cells in the brain. He was compassionate and caring and genuinely concerned for me.

Dr Fenstermaker is superb. Very thorough, and caring. Answers questions in a way that's easy to understand. He explains everything and I trust his judgment. Been his patient for a decade

I have been seeing Dr. Fenstermaker for 17 years, he has always been very attentive, listened to all of my questions and concerns, and responded. Still just as attentive on my followup visits 17 years after my surgeries.

I was seen promptly and listened to carefully. We made a decision about next steps and I was very pleased. I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend him to anyone.

Been seeing him for 23 years. He is always attentive and explains everything. I have recommended him several times

Dr. Fenstermaker saved my life! I had a brain tumor and went through Gammaknife surgery and today the tumor has decreased in size and is not an issue anymore! Dr. Fenstermaker is very kind and explains everything in great detail. He made me feel comfortable with my decision on the proper treatment and you truly couldn't ask for a better doctor!

He took care of my son, he is excellent!

Comfortable, efficient, good report. And still exciting to see him regularly for 24 years since surgeries!!

Dr. Fenstermaker and his team were wonderful. They took plenty of time with me to ask and answer all my questions. He made me feel very comfortable regarding my situation.

Dr. Fenstermaker is not only an excellent surgeon, but he is compassionate and empathetic. His bedside manner is excellent. His explanations are easy to understand and he takes as much time as needed to ensure he answers all of your questions and that you are completely informed before going into surgery. Post operative care is just as excellent. He has an amazing team but still sees you himself to ensure you understand your plan of care. I feel extremely confident that I am receiving the best care.

He took me right away although I was half hour late; he sat and explained everything until I understood. Very patient!

Perfect mix of professional skills and compassion. Great staff as well.

Dr Fenstermaker and his team are wonderful! He listens to concerns is wonderful explaining anything you ask and is very assuring. His nurses are awesome and everyone is very caring. I would highly recommend Dr Fenstermaker

He is the absolute best! My husband had a tumor as big as an orange. Dr Fenstermaker did the surgery and removed the entire tumor There was no neurological difficulties afterwards and has gone back to play golf and tennis weekly.

I’ve had (3) surgeries with Fenstermaker, and my 3rd surgery was to resolve an issue of spinal fluid leaking in my head from my second surgery. Yet (2) months since surgery number 3, my head still has fluid. Fenstermaker told me when it began (2 weeks after surgery) that it wasn’t spinal fluid and everything would be fine. But now he’s talking about a possible shunt. But refuses to answer any questions I have now. After he did my second surgery and the spinal fluid was leaking he also said I would be fine and we’d just have to drain it a couple times. After my third time letting him drain it he said we’d probably have to do it one more time. When I arrived to get it drained the 4th and final time, he changed his mind and said that draining wasn’t an option, we’d have to do surgery to repair the leak. At Roswell they talk about how good of a surgeon he is, but I’m guessing that’s because he never did surgery on them. He’s completely piss poor! Much worse than my first surgery a

Excellent.

I had been seen by another Neurosurgeon from a different medical facility. Not liking the attitude from that Doctor I decided to call Roswell Park CI . I was referred to Dr Fenstermaker and I feel lucky to have him as my Doctor. He and his staff are warm, caring and do everything they can to put you at ease. Dr. Fenstermaker spent over an hour explaining my situation and asking questions my family and I had. He never appeared annoyed with our concerns or questions. He is honest, intelligent, humble and kind. I don’t think you could ask for much more from a Doctor. I’m glad there are still good doctors like him in our area. I felt confident and continue to be confident that I made the right decision choosing him as my surgeon.

I was diagnosed with glioblastoma brain cancer at SUNY Syracuse. I was told my tumor was inoperable. When my son told me about Roswell Park, I called and made an appointment. After hearing my prognosis from Syracuse he said he was confident he could remove the entire tumor. Five days later , in January 2017, he did just that. I went from 6-8 months to live to now nearly two years later other than left peripheral vision loss in my left eye, I live a normal life. Thanks Dr. Fenstermaker!!

Entire staff was very nice and helpful. Made me feel at ease even though the situation was scary for me. I feel blessed to have Dr Fenstermaker and staff taking care of me.

I was facing a serious dilemma when I came to Dr. Fenstermakers office. From the moment I walked in I felt a sense of peace. His staff was friendly and greeted me with a smile. The were courteous and caring. It is no surprise that Dr. Fenstermaker was just as amazing! He was thorough in his explanation as well as patient he told me we can take as much time as needed to answer my questions. I'm grateful to God that doctors like him still exist as they are extremely rare! Thank you!